In the Spirit: Creationists, evolutionists commingle at Dane County Fair
In the Spirit: Creationists, evolutionists commingle at Dane County FairDOUG ERICKSON, Wisconsin State Journal, 7/17/2013, originalFor many years, Nick Schweitzer thought of the Dane County Fair as simply a place to view farm machinery and eat shaved ice.
Then two years ago, he read an article in the Wisconsin State Journal about a woman who set up a booth at the fair to convince people the universe is only 6,000 years old. Schweitzer thinks the universe is considerably older, so he decided to get involved.
“I wanted another point of view represented — the scientific one,” said Schweitzer, 66, a retired attorney for the state and an adjunct professor at the UW Law School.
So last year, with the support of the Madison Area Coalition of Reason, he paid for his own booth, one with fossils on loan from the UW-Madison Geology Museum that researchers estimate are about 450 million years old. He’s back again this year at the five-day fair, which opens today, July 17, at Alliant Energy Center in Madison and runs through Sunday.
Both years, Schweitzer has asked fair management for a booth on the opposite side of Exhibition Hall from the creationists. He prefers to describe what he’s doing as a counterbalance to the creationists, rather than a direct challenge.
“My goal isn’t to be confrontational to those with strongly held religious beliefs about this,” said Schweitzer, who describes himself as a humanist and an amateur scientist. “It’s to present evidence to people still thinking about it.”
His booth never mentions creationists. The displays — from pictures taken by the Hubble Space Telescope to a reproduction of a mastodon tooth — would fit in just fine at any school science fair. Kids can make a bracelet that looks like a strand of DNA or plant a few seeds in a test tube and watch them grow at home.
“It’s really an outreach opportunity for science,” he said.
The booth’s information is based on “mountains of empirical evidence, as opposed to an ancient text, which is the basis for the creationist booth,” said Leslie Starczewski, coordinator of the Madison Area Coalition of Reason. “There really is no comparison.”
The creationist booth also is back. Mary Weigand, 50, the part-time nurse from West Bend who heads it up, said this is her fourth consecutive year at the Dane County Fair and that she will be at a handful of other county fairs in the region.
Her booth also displays fossils, ones she said show there’s been no progression of life over time as evolutionists claim. She says a better explanation for the formation of fossils is the catastrophic flood described in the book of Genesis. That was about 4,500 years ago, she said.
She has viewed Schweitzer’s booth. She doesn’t agree with its conclusions, but it’s a free country, she said.
“I think it’s great people can be out talking about these issues, as long as we’re truthful about what we’re showing and not misleading people,” she said. She considers her booth the more scientifically sound of the two.
Is it cost-effective to try to engage people about such a heavy topic at a county fair?
“We love being at the fair,” Weigand said. “It’s a lot of seed planting — putting that seed of information in people’s minds. We have great conversations with people, some short, some long. People are very interested.”
Schweitzer said he’s still determining the answer.
“Out of the thousands who walk past on their way to the petting zoo, maybe a couple of dozen are truly engaged,” he said. “So is it worth it? The ideologue in me should say, ‘Absolutely.’ I guess I’ll assess it again after this year.”
For now, he feels it’s important to be part of the conversation.